Eliot Goldthorp plays for Lexington Sporting Club in USL League One, which is the third level of soccer. He scored in a 5-0 win over amateur club Souther Indiana. In cup competitions, clubs from different levels in the same country that can include amateur clubs play each other. The U.S. Open Cup used to include all Major League Soccer (MLS) clubs, but it does not anymore. Lexington's next U.S. Open Cup game is April 1 at Columbus Crew 2, which is like aa Triple-A club of MLS's Columbus Crew. In the New York area, the Second Round will have Westchester Soccer club host New York Pancyprian Freedoms in Mount Vernon. New York Pancyprian Freedoms plays in Queens, and is an amateur club that won the U.S. Open Cup in 1980, 1982, and 1983 when there were no professional clubs because the North American Soccer League (NASL) clubs did not participate. Last year Goldthorp scored 10 goals in 22 games for Whitecaps 2, which is like a Triple-A club of MLS's Vancouver Whitecaps. Vancouver Whitecaps put him on the roster for one MLS game, but he did not play. Wikipedia says that his sister Francesca scored for England in the 2021 Women's Rugby League World Cup.
Edit: Another players from us scored. Jacob Woznicki was drafted by the Los Angeles Galaxy, but apparently they did not keep him, and he now plays for an amateur club near us, the Long Island Rough Riders, who are in the fourth level. He scored for them in an extra time loss to Charlotte Independence. Somebody on X wondered if the Galaxy did not want him or if he stayed in college, but our roster already had him as a graduate. NCAA players are allowed to play for amateur clubs. Jordan Morris was discovered by the United States National Team while in college. He was allowed to play for the national team and keep NCAA eligibility as long as the national team did not pay him like they paid everyone else.
Edit: The aforementioned New York Pancyprian Freedoms have a player from us, Joe Holland. His Wikipedia page does not know of a club for him after 2019. They won at FC Cincinnati 2 in penalty kicks 5-4 after neither club scored in 120 minutes, and Holland scored a penalty kick.